Panel Conversation: Artistic Process and Generative Art

Panel Conversation: Artistic Process and Generative Art

Panel Conversation: Artistic Process and Generative Art

4 years ago

Moderated by artnome, this panel explores the artistic process behind generative and AI art with three leading artists, Helena SarinDavid Young, and Alexander Reben. The goal is to help collectors and potential collectors to develop a more nuanced understanding of how decisions around tools and process ultimately shape the work they share with the world.

28

SuperRare

SuperRare is a marketplace to collect and trade unique, single-edition digital artworks.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice

The Creation of an Artificial Artist

The Creation of an Artificial Artist

by Pindar Van Arman

The Creation of an Artificial Artist

4 years ago

We are working to make a generative art system that achieves human parity. If this A.I. system is successful, it will force us to consider the possibility that all art is generative.

Kitty Simpson and I, Pindar Van Arman, are artists teaching our creative processes to a machine. The machine is artonomous, an artificially creative painting robot. Kitty is teaching it how to take photographic portraits and I am teaching it how to paint them. The goal of our project is to teach it everything we know then let it begin to create art completely autonomously.

artonomous is fifteen years in the making and has already completed thousands of “hand-painted” canvases. It has a paint brush in its gripper, a camera on its arm, and a collection of more than two dozen A.I. algorithms fighting for control of the next mark it makes. Some of its algorithms are procedural, others are feedback loops, and many are neural networks attempting to imitate how the human brain creates. While each of these algorithms has an important role in completing its artwork, we will be concentrating on improving the neural networks responsible for its creativity and imagination.

Our approach will follow traditional artistic training using vigorous practice and reflection. 

1: Kitty begins the process by providing the robot with a curated set of portrait photographs. 

2: artonomous then paints a study of the portraits using its array of A.I. 

3: Once the painting is complete, the robot analyzes each brush stroke and final painting by incorporating it as training data for its neural networks. 

4: Every eighth study, artonomous attempts to create a unique portrait from its imagination. 

5: We critique the imagined portrait and decide on how to improve artonomous’ creative process.

6: I then make adjustments to artonomous’ hardware, code, and neural networks to better actualize it as an artist.

Repeat

The process then begins anew with another set of photo shoots, in a creative feedback loop.

We do not know how long it will take us to improve artonomous’ creative process to the point it achieves human parity. We expect it will take several years and hundreds if not thousands of cycles. Part of this project is recording the progress being made, how its is being made, and exactly what improvements, if any, are occuring.

As part of this record, we will be tokenizing the imagined portrait from each cycle on superrare.  Expect new tokenized artwork every 8-10 days as this is typically how long each learning cycle takes. The form of these artworks will vary.  Some will be animated gifs of the neural network thinking, others will be still frames of the finished painting, and some will be timelapses. Regardless of form, the one thing each will have in common is that it will be based on the original artwork created by artonomous in that cycle of its learning.

Look for the first tokenized artwork by artonomous titled “x00000000“. It is the first of what we believe will be an exciting and interesting exploration of the creative process and the emergence of an artificial artist.

1

Pindar Van Arman

Pindar Van Arman is an AI Artist exploring the intersection of human and artificial creativity. Winner of the Robot Art Prize in 2018, his robots use a broad array of deep learning, generative algorithms, and feedback loops to bring his AI creations into the material world one brush stroke at a time.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice

The Shaman Convergence

The Shaman Convergence

The Shaman Convergence

4 years ago

Lawrence Lee, acclaimed Contemporary Southwestern artist, and Bård Ionson, coder with a keen eye and an artistic bent, have begun a fascinating journey of collaboration that melds paintings with modern artificial intelligence technology.

Lee’s “magic people” inhabit a separate reality that seems to be of another world–a multidimensional one. By combining one of the original human creative outlets, painting, and advanced math with new technologies, a multitude of mages, seers, shamans and sages has been born.

Just a Few of Lee’s Original paintings

This is a creation built on a lifetime of Lee’s creations at the easel. Bård used over 250 Lee paintings to train a machine learning / artificial intelligence system and used his own creative skills to perfect the output of the software and to curate results.  Lee then worked to identify the best of the generated images and used his digital painting skills and immense creativity to improve on what Bård produced. With each iteration, new possibilities were revealed, and the pair are excited by the prospect of further development, incorporating new technologies as they become available and following the lead of some of the images produced thus far into new, previously unimagined areas.

Bård is now taking the improved results to teach the AI model all over again.

The goal was to expand the creative palette like a hallucinatory dream. Controlled by Bård with training selections, the AI produced a googleplex of possible random outcomes. Lawrence and Bård have hand-selected the best of each production run from the machine, and Lawrence has worked to unearth these new shamans and the landscapes they inhabit by enhancing them further and augmenting their otherworldly qualities in an attempt to better understand their roots and to release their powers. 

Ionson and Lee will be releasing the series of images created, called Convergence, as weekly package drops of three still images and one video on SuperRare. Find them starting on June 23. The winning bidder will have the option to redeem an exclusive 1 of 1 , 10″ X 10″ inch print valued at $250 created by Lawrence in his Arizona atelier. Coupon code will expire after two months if not redeemed.

Convergence Ab The Bård artificial intelligence version |  Convergence Ab – After Lawrence Lee turns it into art. 

Converging Artists

The mystical Shamans of Lawrence Lee are famous in the genre of American Southwest Art. Lawrence has painted thousands of quality paintings of these Shaman. Which is just one of the things that attracted me to work with him.

I got to know Lawrence through our work together on establishing an industry-wide convention for secondary sale royalties. For months a group of artists met virtually on Discord to discuss and plan ways to promote artist resale rights. He has also given art career advice to many of us based on his half-century of experience in the competitive art market.

I approached Lawrence about a collaboration knowing that he had a lifetime of artwork to build on. I suspected that we just might be able to make something special by combining my somewhat unique artificial intelligence art techniques. One thing that makes artificial intelligence art work right now is a large library of content. One needs thousands of images to train a GAN (Generative Adversarial Network) on how to make copies of an oeuvre. 

He was very enthusiastic, and within an hour we agreed to work together.

Parts of his work really drew me into thinking this could work. I have an affinity for southwest art from growing up in Denver Colorado. He has lots of work. Often his work is square, which is ideal for AI art as code is built for 1:1 ratio work. His work has an otherworldly feel that I thought would lend itself to the artifacts that GAN introduces. And I really wanted to experiment with subject matter that was original and unique.

Start of an Idea

This was partly inspired by Robbie Barrat’s collaboration with Ronan Barrot, a French painter, called Infinite Skulls. Ronan has painted hundreds of small square skull paintings over a lifetime, and Robbie trained a machine learning / artificial intelligence GAN with them. Robbie curated what the GAN generated. Then Ronan would paint over them to fix them or he would paint new ones based on what was produced.

The Process

Lawrence liked the concept and we decided to move forward. He sent me 200 or so images of his shamanistic works. Unfortunately, many photos of his early Shaman paintings were lost. I was able to pull a number of them from various places on the internet. And with some manipulation, I was able to make many variations of those by altering them slightly–or sometimes drastically–using AI style transfer techniques.

In the process, I built about five different models and ended up with three that were sufficient. One key is that the GAN was not able to build good looking torsos and faces at the same time. One model ended up being trained on half-length subjects and the other on head shots. And then we have the original third model that makes surrealistic blobs with eyes and Shaman as viewed on a bad trip.

As I experimented with each model’s output I sent Lawrence a large batch of images. Some were random and some were curated choices by me. He says I have overloaded him with a year’s worth of ideas and images. He began finding the best ones and then experimenting with what to change to make them look like a Shaman should.

It was difficult because the first batches were fairly poor. He provided input on what needed to be corrected in the training and I took some of his initial experiments on fixing them and added them back into the training set. I removed thousands of images that were “corrupting” the training. Many of these bad images were introduced by my attempts to augment the training set. So now I directed the training on the faces by providing more headshots. We iterated on this.

The faces were just full of chins and mouths or just blobs. But Lawrence started enhancing them.

(Early AI GAN faces)

Then Lawrence had the idea of finding the best parts from multiple images and putting them together. Or perhaps I thought he said something along those lines. But in the middle of the night trying to sleep I think why not make a separate model for heads and build on top of an existing open-source model of faces. By cropping the heads I could build a separate model just for heads. I also include headshots and self portraits of Lawrence Lee.

Lawrence Lee Self Portrait 

In the meantime Lawrence created amazing pieces by augmenting the output of the GAN using Procreate and an iPad. Sometimes he invented an ancient god from just an abstract blob. 

The blob from the AI model

One of the Artificial Intelligence generated images.
Or he drew a new face on an amazing flowing cloak.

Once I was able to produce better faces I sent him a large batch of those. I had also been producing latent morphing videos commonly seen with GAN based art. He found that by stopping the video in the middle of a transition between faces he could find some good faces to build on.

We have ideas for improving the models. The next attempt might be to use high resolution images of just the faces including the new digital works. And also making sure they are all in a face forward position.

Part of the fun I have in making artificial intelligence art is the strange things it can produce when experimenting and adding things to the model just to throw it off a bit. This has been a rewarding and joy producing project to work on.

With his skills in manipulating color and shadow he has pulled out the best features of these beings. I am so excited to present these to the world. They are so much better than I could ever dream of being able to create.

Please find these Shaman works we call Convergence on SuperRare on the profiles of Lawrence Lee and Bård Ionson 

Lawrence is one of the small number of fine artists in the space of tokenized art because he is always looking for ways to expand and learn new things. He has been a professional artist for over 40 years.  He is one of the original adopters of non-fungible tokens on SuperRare for his digital art. In addition he has created computer art from early in the personal computer age. 

Bård Ionson is an artist who is a relative beginner with art but has spent a career working with computers and programming. He is now creating digital art and video art using oscilloscopes, scanners and artificial intelligence technologies.

1

Bård Ionson

Bård Ionson is an artist who is a relative beginner with art but has spent a career working with computers and programming. He is now creating digital art and video art using oscilloscopes, scanners and artificial intelligence technologies.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice

Two Sides of the Crypto Coin

Two Sides of the Crypto Coin

Two Sides of the Crypto Coin

4 years ago

#1 of the Beholder Series – Atramentous Behemoth 

Towards the start of the year an email landed in my inbox that would prove to have an interesting effect on my life. The email simply read: “WE NEED TO TALK!” The email was from a good friend of mine and extremely talented virtual reality artist by the name of ‘Metageist’.

If you’re wondering, my name is Paradoxx. I’m an artist, filmmaker, and writer from the UK. Paradoxx is not my real name…obviously. It is however the alias I’ve been known by in recent times. In fact, it has been the name and identity that two separate artists have been sharing for some time now. No, before you ask, the other artist isn’t Metageist, but this did all start when I received the email from them.

The last time I received a message like this from Metageist was years before, and that message led me down the rabbit hole which is CryptoCurrency. I became obsessed with this new ‘magic internet money’ and I fully blame Metageist for the days, weeks, months, and years I have spent glued to my phone watching the crypto markets.

So when I saw this new email my initial thoughts were: ‘Oh god, what this time?’. We set up a telephone meeting the following day and a very excited Metageist proceeded to spill the beans on their latest discovery: Crypto Art.

It took me some weeks to fully understand exactly why Metageist was so excited but when the penny finally dropped, I was hooked!

As with anything exciting in peoples’ lives, I wanted to talk about it. Most of my friends were so uninterested it was painful. Except for one, an American artist and long term friend known as ‘Siege187’. I have never actually met Siege in the real world. He lives on the other side of the planet, but this has not stopped us from working together on a plethora of projects over the years. Siege is that guy you go to with crazy ideas, which I have a lot of, and they simply say: Let’s do it!

Over the next few weeks, I spent a lot of time researching to better understand this strange new movement called CryptoArt. This inspired many conversations about what type of art each of us would create if we ever applied for artist status on the SuperRare platform. 

Siege and I have a twin-like taste in film and art, and predictably we started suggesting similar art projects. This sparked the longstanding habit of riffing off each other’s ideas and working from one another’s strengths. We were soon joking that It would be very efficient if we could just merge our brains and create a super artist…

Just to be clear, we did not undergo this evil scientist-esque medical procedure to merge our brains together, but we did decide to join forces. 

#2 of the Beholder Series – Introspection

Prior to this time, Siege had no previous experience with the confusing world of crypto and for the most part preferred to avoid social media. On the other hand, I come from a media background and had no problem with the idea of spearheading the social media and PR for the project. It was decided pretty early on that Siege would be a silent partner and preferred to stay completely anonymous and unnamed.

With that decision made, we started the creative process of working on a joint project.
There were a lot of options to choose from based on our collective artistic skills. We experimented with a range of styles and ideas but eventually landed on something we both agreed was ‘super dope’.

I come from a television and film background in the UK and specialize in time-lapse photography and digital art. We noticed that there was a limited range of video art and as far as we could tell, no time-lapse art in the crypto art scene. Consequently we decided to utilize my video fx compositing skills for our creations.

Siege specializes in digital art and classifies himself as ‘almost entirely an outsider artist’ with some formal training. Aside from digital painting he also paints traditionally in both oil and acrylic and on rare occasions creates in other mediums. 

#3 of the Beholder Series: Judgement

The word that kept coming up time and time again in our conversations was ‘cinematic’.
We wanted to create art that evokes the same emotions one feels whilst watching an epic movie. We had the time-lapse which is great by itself, but it needed something more to bring the ‘WOW factor.’ I recalled that at one point Siege had been doodling up some monster art in his spare time for fun. We experimented layering one of his doodles on top of a time-lapse video I had shot years before and very quickly realized we liked the look; and we were onto something special. The idea was developed into the first series released by Paradoxx; the ‘Beholder series’. At the time of writing there are three pieces tokenized on SuperRare.

The creative process begins with traveling to a pre-selected location to shoot the time-lapse photography. I take account of the best framing, lighting, and image interval. Back at the computer I video call Siege and screen share the color grading process. We can spend hours at a time discussing all aspects of design for the creatures in our heads and doodling up mockup ideas using online shared paint pads. Eventually, after numerous drafts a ‘Beholder’ is born: an end result composited from two different art mediums: A mutual collaborative process between two artists.

#0 of the Beholder Series – Video prototype 

That first video prototype had a ‘monster’ standing in the middle of a busy town square. It seemed odd that none of the busy passers-by in the scene noticed the hulking creature, some even passing right through it. Between Siege and I, we do have all the answers to the questions surrounding the series: ‘Why are the creatures there?’. ‘Where did they come from?’. ‘Do they pose a threat?’. Sadly we will not be sharing this information – at least not yet.

My training in film taught me to always present clear exposition to the viewer. To tell the story I want to tell. Siege, who has more experience in the conventional art world, has taught me to leave questions unanswered, to create mystery and allow the viewer the chance to explore the art and find their own story. As a writer of fiction and film it goes against all my instincts and I admit it pains me to relinquish that all-powerful control over the narrative. I would however be fascinated to hear other people’s interpretations of the art.

In light of some initial success on the SuperRare platform and the invitation to write this article, we decided that going forward it would be in both of our best interests if Siege187 were to become a named collaborator. Personally I find collaboration exciting, and believe it has endless potential to create amazing projects. With this in mind it is likely that for the foreseeable future the majority of both of our efforts will be in collaborative works released under the Paradoxx name. 

You can find the art from the ‘Beholder series’ released by Paradoxx & Siege under the Paradoxx profile on the SuperRare: https://superrare.com/paradoxx

Feel free to follow me on Twitter for Art drop updates and other crypto-related projects I’m working on: @paradoxxartist

For commission work and PR related inquiries please contact me at [email protected]

Paradoxx out. 

1

Paradoxx

A career working in television and film production inspired Paradoxx to dive headfirst through the whirling portal to bring 'cinematic' to the crypto art scene. Paradoxx is sharing the adventure with a fellow artist and collaborator: 'Siege187'. For the foreseeable future; works released under the Paradoxx name are a collaborative effort from the two artists. Paradoxx & Siege187 are currently working on a series of unnerving supernatural blends of Time-Lapse photography and digital artwork.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice